Bidder Reviews for Silver City Auctions (460)
TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 460 Reviews
All Ratings
Highest Rated
GeorgeWashington, DC
Dec 20, 2023
Richard JNorth Port, FL
Jun 08, 2023
JackSalt Lake City, UT
Jun 07, 2023
Coin Books Misleading
I recently won an auction for 2 coin books, 1 being Buffalo nickels and 1 being Liberty nickels. Nowhere in the listing did it say that the coins were incorrect in the book but when I received the books just about every Liberty nickel date was wrong, this would be fine. Still, it was very annoying that there were coins in rare date slots, for example, there was an 1885 Liberty Nickel filled in but when received it was actually 1890 (which is a MASSIVE rarity and annoying difference.) Thankfully most of the Buffalo nickel dates were correct but overall the amount of wrong dates and common dates in rare slots in both books primarily the V-nickel book is just unacceptable. The only positive experience was that the shipping process was very smooth. I highly advise to be careful bidding with this auction house and hope that Silver City Auctions improves upon this issue in the future. reached out to fix the issue by offering a refund swiftly.
RobertOregon City, OR
Jun 06, 2023
RobertOregon City, OR
Jun 06, 2023
RobertOregon City, OR
Jun 06, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
May 30, 2023
CharlesWasilla, AK
May 24, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
May 23, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
May 19, 2023
May 18, 2023
Jean-DidierHartsdale, NY
May 16, 2023
Product not at described-No response to email.
I bought the lot in good faith, assuming the estimate was on par with the product. However, I should have been more vigilant as the item description needed to be more specific, and no precisions were supplied when requested. Furthermore, about 20 % of the received product was NOT as described (all coins were supposed to be "S" mint mark, 20 % were not) to the description and what I paid for. I contacted the auction house multiple times and am still awaiting a meaningful response. Very disappointed and feeling a little bit scammed. I can only recommend avoiding that company.
glenn Centennial, CO
May 11, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
May 07, 2023
GordonShafter, CA
May 07, 2023
Apr 29, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
Apr 27, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
Apr 26, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
Apr 20, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
Apr 13, 2023
glenn Centennial, CO
Apr 06, 2023
EricGeorgetown, TX
Mar 29, 2023
RichardOttawa, CA
Mar 29, 2023
Great service!!
Thanks for the great item (coin)!! Very happy with the service and shipping to Canada was easy:)
GordonShafter, CA
Mar 28, 2023
MarkJasper, GA
Mar 23, 2023
MikeDeland, FL
Mar 22, 2023
MikeDeland, FL
Mar 22, 2023
FrankLongview, WA
Mar 03, 2023
DeborahFrankfort, IN
Mar 02, 2023
GordonShafter, CA
Feb 28, 2023
RobertOregon City, OR
Feb 25, 2023
Richard JNorth Port, FL
Feb 16, 2023
GordonShafter, CA
Feb 14, 2023
RobertOregon City, OR
Feb 04, 2023
GordonShafter, CA
Feb 03, 2023
RobertOregon City, OR
Jan 24, 2023
RobertOregon City, OR
Jan 24, 2023
GordonShafter, CA
Jan 03, 2023
PeterNew Milford, CT
Dec 06, 2022
MikeDeland, FL
Nov 30, 2022
BobJacksonville, FL
Nov 26, 2022
JohnMesa, AZ
Nov 24, 2022
DamonDallas, TX
Nov 10, 2022
MikeDeland, FL
Nov 08, 2022
MikeDeland, FL
Nov 08, 2022
Great quality, fun auction
I have been very pleased with my purchases. The house is very responsive and shipping is pretty fast. Descriptions are accurate. I am a return customer.
MikeDeland, FL
Oct 09, 2022
GordonShafter, CA
Sep 28, 2022
FrederickHouston, TX
Sep 20, 2022
Accurate description, very nice item!
Fast shipping and item arrived exactly as described. Great seller!!!
chrisVentura, CA
Sep 13, 2022
JohnBuckeye, AZ
Sep 09, 2022
View:
50
TOP