Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Online Auctions, OH - Read over 121 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Online Auctions (121)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 121 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Steve
Brentwood, TN

Apr 28, 2024
Mr Taylor is Among The Best
Have no doubts when buying from Dave Taylor. It's authentic and always well packed!
Report

Terry
Walbridge, OH

Apr 28, 2024
Zoli Zouave
Very nice to deal with. A plus was I was able to pick up my item because we live in the same area. If he puts something that up catches my eye again, I will bid again.
Report

Clark
Baytown, TX

Apr 28, 2024
Great Service
All around great service from start to finish. A great dealer to deal with.
Report

Don
Howell, MI

Jan 18, 2024
Great place to buy from
Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques is a great place to buy from. You can trust that what you're buying is what Dave says it is. The items are shipped quickly and have always arrived in good shape.
Report

Ron
Cheraw, SC

Jan 11, 2024

Marc
Oakland Park, FL

Jan 04, 2024
“Very Reliable”
This was my first time dealing with Dave Taylor, and I will most likely do so again. Very reliable and friendly, with great items. A top rating of two rabbit ears up!! (\ (\ .) o_ (��) (��)
Report

Roger
Wooster, OH

Dec 31, 2023
I had a good experence.
I had a good experience with the auction. My item was well packed for shipping and I received it in great time.
Report

Matthew
Chandler, AZ

Dec 31, 2023
Excellent
A + + + + +
Report

Alan
Rockford, IL

Dec 31, 2023
Honest knowledgeable seller
Dave is an honest knowledgeable seller (quick delivery, responds promptly to questions, accurately describes his genuine antiques, trustworthy)
Report

Louis
Chagrin Falls, OH

Dec 31, 2023
Prompt answers and delivery
Had an excellent experience! Payment was easy and delivery prompt. As I was out of town I had delivery made to another address. That was done without any problems. Thank you Lou
Report

Janet
Stamford, CT

Dec 26, 2023

Luke
St Petersburg, FL

Oct 15, 2023
Items damaged upon shipping owner was unprofessional
When contacting the company about a damaged item the owner contacted me back and the whole conversation was me listening to him explaining the excuses as to why my issue was ‘ not a big deal ’ one of the items I received had partially fallen out of the lamp shade package (they ran out of appropriate Gun size shipping boxes) and the barrel of this historic black powder weapon was damaged. So I then have to take photos of the packaging and send them to him which he never gave me an email or working phone number to do this. I not have a item I want to return as it was not in the same condition due to no fault of my own as I had won it.. the disrespect and lack of consideration for the historical value and care of the items his greedy self Indulgent business owner displays is disgusting and a true stain and burden on the industry. I am still waiting for his email and contact info to send him the photos of the packages.. Buyer beware this company needs to improve how it handles historical items and the owner could use some serious humility when dealing with customers …
Report
Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Online AuctionsOct 19, 2023
I am put off by your review. I told you to send photos of the damaged packaging as UPS expressly requires the packaging be examined by a UPS claims representative for any insurance claim. You never sent pictures, and then admitted you had discarded the damaged box. That eliminated any chance for a UPS claim, I still extended you the option of returning the gun to me for a refund or having the little brass thimble reattached at my expense. That was the ONLY damage, an inconsequential inch long brass tube had been dislodged from the underside of the barrel. It could be soldered back in place in five minutes. It did not affect the value of the percussion fowler in the least. I had no problem accepting the gun back, it was fine. I heard nothing from you, and now many months later you post a ranting hateful review. Your review is untruthful... You have my email and phone numbers on every document generated by Live Auctioneers, yet you claim you couldn't contact me or my office. Your post sounds like an angry email someone writes after consuming too many adult beverages. Hmmm? We will take you off the approved bidders list and solve this problem.

Steve
Warrenton, VA

Aug 26, 2023

Ben
Zionsville, IN

Aug 26, 2023

Randy G.
Las Vegas, NV

Aug 21, 2023
CIVIL War belt
As described
Report

Chad
Norwell, MA

Aug 20, 2023
He is great.
Always a good experience dealing with Dave!
Report

Martin
Hove, GB

Aug 20, 2023
Excellent for hard to find antique arms. Fair estimates, Easy to bid online.
Excellent coverage of Antique arms. Well described, enough pictures focusing on the right shots to allow absentee buyers confidence in bidding. Ability to follow bids on items you want to win before the auction starts. Fast shipping within U. S. A. As a foreign buyer will ship to a nominated FFL company for onward shipping by them.
Report

Scott
Rapid River, MI

Aug 20, 2023
I have purchased many items from Dave over the years and have always been satisfied.
I have purchased many items from Dave over the years and have always been satisfied.
Report

Mark
Waterford, CT

Aug 20, 2023

Robert
Versailles, KY

Aug 20, 2023

Peter
Plainfield, IL

Aug 20, 2023
Dave Taylor did a excellent job on description and delivery. Live Auctions did poor job billing.
Dave Taylor did an excellent job on description and delivery. In fact, I think he under described the gun. He was very helpful with my questions. But I was very disappointed with Online Auctions. They doubled the charges buy automatically charging my credit card even though I had already sent a check directly to Dave Taylor and it had been deposited in Taylors account. What was bad about it is that I could not reach Online Auctions by phone. It seems Online Auctions cannot be reached by phone. What's that about? My e-mails took a long time to get answered. I needed to get this done before my billing period because my credit card limit would have been exceeded. Luckily, we made it buy one day. I am not a techy I am a cash person and not being able to call a company with problems makes me very uncomfortable. With that in mind I am very tentative in working with Online Auction in the future.
Report

Scott
Waverly, IA

Aug 20, 2023
Very Satisfied Auction Experience!
Great experience. Dave answered all my questions. Received my item and was pleased as it was as described in the auction description.
Report

Anderson
Columbus, OH

Apr 06, 2023
Great Seller!
Highly recommended, knowledgeable and professional!
Report

Evan
Mount Vernon, OH

Mar 26, 2023

Wayne
Ogden, UT

Feb 09, 2023
Very well organized-
I received this old ammo fairly quickly and it was packaged well-Protected. I am very pleased with the first transaction with Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Auctions.
Report

Philip
Jeffersonville, IN

Jan 09, 2023
Firearm Operational Status
Seller holds a good auction and has a reasonable return policy if you are dissatisfied. Seller was slow to respond to e-mail questions/inquiries. Shipping rates were very fair.
Report
Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Online AuctionsFeb 05, 2023
Sorry to hear there was a problem with that lot. We stand behind everything we sell and you are more than welcome to return the lot for a full refund.

Allen
Mooresville, IN

Jan 09, 2023
Topnotch
Excellent transaction in every respect! DT is an esteemed longtime dealer, entirely trustworthy with a wealth of knowledge. Still the best!
Report

Jerry
Cinnaminson, NJ

Jan 06, 2023

Ed
Annandale, VA

Jan 04, 2023
No surprises
Rifle was well described with excellent pictures. I've bought from Dave Taylor 10 + times and have never been disappointed in the purchases or the process of receiving them.
Report

Steve
Brentwood, TN

Jan 01, 2023
Dave is among the best!
Never a worry when buying from Dave Taylor!
Report

Herman
Bowling Green, KY

Oct 27, 2022

Carlo
Ocala, FL

Oct 23, 2022
Fair Honest knowledgeable Dealer
I have never been so happy to make a major purchase as I am with Dave Taylor, he sells nothing but the real thing with fast and fair shipping as a matter of fact you know the shipping price before you purchase. That combined with no anxiety as to what you will receive. What you see is what you get and what you get is the Genuine article. My only complaint is that he doesn't have an auction every week. Thank you Dave looking forward to your next auction.
Report

Scott
Centreville, VA

Jun 19, 2022
Great Experience
I have won multiple items using this auction site. Items are accurately described, the payment process was easy, and items have always been well wrapped for shipping. I will continue to use this site to acquire excellent historical artifacts.
Report

Connette
Cambridge, MN

Jun 12, 2022

Steve
Brentwood, TN

May 01, 2022
Great First Purchase
My purchase couldn't have gone smoother. Mr Taylor was prompt and courteous in our exchanges and the rifle arrived well packed and as described. I couldn't ask for more.
Report

Ed
Annandale, VA

Mar 23, 2022

Jose
San Juan, PR

Mar 14, 2022

Daniel
Stow, OH

Mar 13, 2022

John
Austin, TX

Jan 04, 2022
Civil War Dave is a terrible communicator
Dave Taylor is unhinged, yelling at me on the phone. This auctioneer doesn't respond to emails and provides phone numbers that ring through to no voicemail. He must still be living back in the 1800s as this is not how modern commerce operates. Would not recommend.
Report
Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Online AuctionsJan 04, 2022
This bidder bounced a check for over $1, 300.00 a month ago and then claimed he could not reach our office no matter how hard he tried over the next three weeks. Lies and excuses tend to make me angry. He is blocked from bidding.

LLOYD
Salem, VA

Dec 27, 2021
Dave Taylor's Civil War Antiques Online AuctionsDec 30, 2021
I have no idea what is referring to. He bid on two buttons, paid for them, and received them weeks ago.

Jay
Grapevine, TX

Dec 27, 2021

Shane
Newhall, CA

Dec 26, 2021

Tim
Minneapolis, MN

Dec 26, 2021

James
Port Chester, NY

Dec 26, 2021
Next auction
Very easy on bidding, great service and fast shipping. Looking forward towards next auction.
Report

Robert
Union, NJ

Nov 08, 2021

Richard
Macclenny, FL

Nov 08, 2021
Buy Civil War items with confidence
One of the oldest and most trusted Civil War dealers in business today.
Report

James
Raleigh, NC

Nov 07, 2021

Greg
Clifton, VA

Nov 07, 2021

Katherine
Lowville, NY

Nov 07, 2021
I would order form Dave Taylor again!
Great to deal with. I would order form Dave Taylor again!
Report

Brent
Littleton, CO

Jun 19, 2021
Historical Leather Item
Purchaser went smoothly and I ave no complaints. Positive experience. Thanks
Report
View:
50
TOP