Bidder Reviews for Catalog Projects (54)
TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 54 Reviews
All Ratings
Highest Rated
RichardDover, NH
Apr 16, 2024
ColinBrooklyn, NY
Apr 15, 2024
Young SunPhiladelphia, PA
Mar 20, 2024
BenjaminBaton Rouge, LA
Jan 10, 2024
Great Selection and Service!
Always excited to see what they have on auction and they are very responsive to shipping questions.
RichardDover, NH
Jan 04, 2024
DerekCambridge, MA
Dec 29, 2023
OnikNew York, NY
Nov 06, 2023
MarkChicago, IL
Oct 22, 2023
jasperNew York, NY
Oct 22, 2023
FrancisYorktown Heights, NY
Aug 16, 2023
DerekCambridge, MA
Aug 16, 2023
DavidBrooklyn, NY
Aug 16, 2023
Rare and unique items
I've been watching Catalog Sale's auctions for awhile now and purchased a music flyer from them in their July auction. Pickup was super easy in NYC. No issues and the item was exactly as described. 100 % recommend these guys.
NatalieQueens, NY
Jul 16, 2023
DerekCambridge, MA
May 14, 2023
WilliamRed Hook, NY
Apr 30, 2023
DerekCambridge, MA
Apr 28, 2023
MichaelWashington, DC
Mar 12, 2023
JonathanLos Angeles, CA
Jan 13, 2023
BobNeptune, NJ
Jan 06, 2023
OliverBrooklyn, NY
Jan 06, 2023
Great experience 10/10
Cool auction house with great listings. Always been able to get the help I need before for bidding!
NICKLawrence, KS
Dec 09, 2022
Catalog Sale offers wonderful antique photography and has great customer service. Although the item was not as described, we were able to work out a solution in a professional manner for both parties involved. Thank you so much. I will cherish these two tintypes.
KoviLong Beach, CA
Nov 28, 2022
ChristopherIndianapolis, IN
Nov 17, 2022
ElijahChicago, IL
Oct 20, 2022
TiptonBrooklyn, NY
Sep 19, 2022
KerryClarkston, GA
Sep 18, 2022
JenniferChicago, IL
Jul 10, 2022
SolomonPlantation, FL
Jun 29, 2022
MATTHEWTuckahoe, NY
Feb 28, 2022
Catalog Sale team are intensely involved!
Truly in-the-know staff with massive affinity for their particular expertise. Hunters and finders of fresh & fascinating objects.
DerekCambridge, MA
Feb 27, 2022
AdamTarrytown, NY
Feb 24, 2022
Keen Eye
These guys have a very good eye for art and objects, and it's a exciting, elctecic mix. I got a chance to meet them when I picked up and they were friendly and interesting. I also like the clean, uncluttered photography in how they present their lots, all very well done. Bravo and look forward to your future auctions.
MattBrooklyn, NY
Jan 07, 2022
EricRidgewood, NY
Jan 07, 2022
OliverBrooklyn, NY
Dec 29, 2021
DerekCambridge, MA
Dec 29, 2021
GregLos Angeles, CA
Dec 28, 2021
Catalog Sale is POWER!
Very impressed with every aspect of this wonderful new auction house. Beautifully curated sales with an extremely interesting and diverse selection of great art and design. Also, super easy and professional to do business with. I'm already looking forward to their next sale! 5 STARS!
Dec 27, 2021
One Stop Shopping!!!
Won item, received invoice, called to pay and arrange shipping and everything was done in-house and the process was seamless!!! I requested info and possibility of acquiring additional works and the like was made available!!! Looking forward to their next auction!!! 🙏
EdwardBrooklyn, NY
Oct 18, 2021
WilliamRed Hook, NY
Oct 17, 2021
DerekCambridge, MA
Oct 17, 2021
BrianBrooklyn, NY
Oct 03, 2021
ClaireLos Angeles, CA
Aug 07, 2021
dependable, thoughtful!!
beautiful and thoughtful work, great to coordinate with and thrilled about my successful bids
AlanLong Island City, NY
Jul 29, 2021
Great new auction house
Has all the components of a legendary auction house. These guys are real curators, offering unique and exquisite pieces that range in genres. Easy to deal with as well so thats nice.
EvanBremen, ME
Jul 29, 2021
Most interesting selection online
Great selection of unusual and exceptional items. I purchased two items from the first sale and am happy with both. They were well packed and arrived safely. My only suggestion would be for more photos and condition description of each item. Overall a great experience and I look forward to future auctions and doing business again.
MichaelOak Park, IL
Jul 28, 2021
Great eye for curiosities and unique objects
Excellent curation and great customer service. Very impressive selection of unique works, often with stories and provenance to add to the allure. I received photos and information quickly when I inquired and the purchases arrived quickly. Love my new pieces! Looking forward to the next sale.
KimNew York, NY
Jul 28, 2021
Unique pieces!
Great and unique pieces! Smooth process and communication. Will definitely keep an eye out for their future auctions.
BeauConcord, MA
Jul 28, 2021
Great and Unique New Addition to Auction World
Very exciting to see a new take on auction curation and material. I can’t wait to see what they come up with going forward!!!
SarahRidgewood, MN
Jul 28, 2021
A pleasure to do business
Working with Catalog Sale was a pleasure-they answered my questions thoroughly and promptly, the invoice came within a day of the auction and was very easy to pay online, coordinating the shipment was as simple as getting a few quotes from a short list of recommended carriers and the product was exactly as pictured in their images. Will certainly keep an eye out for their future auctions.
IanArlington, MA
Jul 27, 2021
Quality. Authenticity. Service.
To potential buyers and consignors-this is a labor of love. This means you can expect honest and upfront service from folks who have a clear understanding of the market. Items are interesting, thoughtfully considered, and clearly presented. Service is quick and sincere. Place your bids... otherwise, buyer's remorse will follow.
JonathanSterling, CO
Jul 27, 2021
Dishonest Description
I thought I had purchased 6 photographs due to the fact that the proudcut description twice used that term (and nothing else) to advertise the lot. Needless to say I'm more than a little upset to have just opened the package (which was its own ordeal to get) to find 6 postcards, not even remotely worth what I payed for. Catalog Sale referenced a photographer stamp on the back, and there are stamps of a sort there, but they are also clearly identified as "POST CARD" in large printed type on each. No way they could have missed that and confused these for actual photos.
Catalog SaleJul 27, 2021
Hey Jonathan, This is our mistake! While what you purchased are in fact photographs, we failed to clarify on the postcard factor, which was an oversight. These photographs would’ve been done in a small run by the photographer, and thus were stamped by him. Please send an email directly to info@ catalogsale.com, and we will issue you a full refund and a return shipping label!
View:
50
TOP